The ATO’s 2025 audit triggers are data-driven and entity-wide. From BAS mismatches and STP errors to contractor misclassification and crypto-linked structures, businesses are flagged before contact is made. Proactive reviews and internal controls are key to audit readiness.
The ATO’s business audit playbook in 2025 isn’t random, it’s real-time, AI-driven, and built on structural signals, not just mistakes. Lodging your return late, misclassifying a contractor, or submitting inconsistent BAS data can all silently flag your business for review, even before the ATO picks up the phone.
This year, the ATO’s audit net is designed for accuracy and pressure. Single Touch Payroll, super clearing houses, bank feeds, crypto exchanges, and industry benchmarks are all integrated into one live compliance system. That means your business’s tax visibility extends far beyond what’s on a tax return.
We help business owners, CFOs, and directors get ahead of those audit triggers with pre-lodgement reviews, multi-entity structuring, and industry-specific tax compliance planning. In this guide, we’ll show you:
- How the ATO flags risk inside your BAS, STP, and contractor records
- Where red flags appear for GST, director compliance, and income splitting
- Why your industry, e.g. e-commerce, construction, or professional services, shapes your audit exposure
- What systems and structures reduce your risk before lodgement
- How our Tax Advisory and CFO Services help create audit-ready operations year-round
In an environment where the ATO doesn’t ask first, audit-readiness is not optional, it’s your front line of defence. Let’s break down what matters most in 2025.
Understanding How the ATO Flags Business Risk
The ATO assesses businesses using predictive indicators built into each lodgement. From Business Activity Statements (BAS) to payroll feeds, each report contributes to a compliance risk score. That score determines which businesses are flagged for further review. Many owners believe audits begin with direct outreach, but in reality, the audit process often begins with silent data modelling.
Risk Indicators Built Into Business Activity Statements (BAS)
The BAS is more than a tax form, it’s a behavioural signal. When your GST turnover fluctuates erratically, or when your PAYG instalments don’t align with wages paid, the ATO notices. Input tax credit patterns are also modelled across your industry and business size. If your claims trend above benchmark without clear support, you are marked for potential review.
Even repeated amended BAS lodgements may elevate your risk category. These corrections suggest uncertainty in bookkeeping or reporting processes, which the ATO views as a sign of weak internal governance. For businesses operating across multiple verticals, property, e-commerce, or food and beverage, ensuring each BAS reflects real activity is critical.
At Blackwattle Tax, we help businesses prepare pre-lodgement reviews that match industry expectations, reducing the probability of being flagged without warning.
Data-Matching Sources the ATO Uses Against You
The ATO’s ability to cross-check information goes far beyond traditional audits. Through Single Touch Payroll (STP), superannuation clearing houses, financial institutions, and contractor payment platforms, your business’s entire footprint is already visible.
If your payroll reports under STP don’t reconcile with your PAYG summaries on the BAS, the ATO detects the mismatch automatically. Similarly, if super payments logged through clearing houses don’t match your reported employer obligations, the system will raise a flag. These mismatches may lead to a “data review event” before you’re even notified.
For clients managing contractors or freelancers, incorrect reporting through TPAR (Taxable Payments Annual Report) can also create red zones. Data matching is particularly effective in the construction, transport, and healthcare sectors, industries where contractor reliance is high.
Need help aligning your records before the ATO compares them? Our bookkeeping team and tax advisers work together to validate cross-source consistency before you hit “lodge.”
ATO Focus Areas for Business Audits in 2025
Not all parts of a tax return carry equal weight. The ATO focuses its audit resources on areas that consistently produce compliance errors or expose gaps in tax integrity. In 2025, these focus areas include workforce classification, GST accuracy, and director-level accountability. Businesses operating in high-risk categories or with inconsistent reporting in these domains face elevated exposure.
Employee vs Contractor Classification Errors
The ATO has intensified its attention on businesses misclassifying workers as contractors when they meet the legal definition of employees. This issue is especially prevalent in industries with high casual labour turnover, such as construction, logistics, and professional services.
If a worker operates under your control, uses your tools, and cannot subcontract or delegate their work, the ATO will likely classify them as an employee. This triggers obligations around PAYG withholding, superannuation, and leave entitlements. Paying them through an ABN or invoice does not alter their legal status.
Failure to meet employer obligations can lead to underpayment penalties, backdated super liabilities, and fines. The ATO uses STP, bank feeds, and even LinkedIn data to identify mismatches. If your contractor arrangements have not been reviewed recently, it’s time to seek guidance through Blackwattle’s tax advisory services before the ATO intervenes.
GST Compliance and Credit Overclaims
GST is another area where overclaiming occurs, often unintentionally. The ATO compares your GST input credits against industry benchmarks. If your business reports disproportionately high credits without corresponding sales or taxable purchases, the system raises a flag.
Common issues include:
- Claiming GST on supplier invoices where no GST was charged
- Using outdated tax codes in accounting systems
- Overstating input credits for assets partially used for private purposes
For businesses managing project-based workflows (e.g. property development or infrastructure), GST timing issues can also occur, particularly when invoices cross reporting periods. The ATO’s data-matching technology is able to trace these invoices back to supplier lodgements.
To avoid unintentional overclaims, our team performs pre-lodgement GST reviews, especially for businesses managing high volumes of purchases or project-based costs. We regularly support clients across property, retail, and e-commerce, where transaction complexity increases the risk of misreporting.
Director-Level Responsibilities and Red Flags
Directors of Australian companies carry personal accountability for key tax obligations. In 2025, the ATO is focusing on director behaviour as a signal of a business’s governance quality. Repeated late lodgements, unremitted PAYG withholding, or non-payment of superannuation can result in Director Penalty Notices (DPNs), making directors personally liable for debts.
Directors operating multiple entities with overlapping financial flows, especially in property investment, trading, or group structures, should pay close attention to entity segregation and intercompany loan documentation. The ATO often investigates whether structures exist for tax deferral purposes, rather than commercial need.
If you’re managing more than one company or trust, ensure your financial strategy includes regular director-level compliance reviews. Our CFO services include director risk mapping and governance reporting tailored to mitigate these specific risks.
Internal Systems That Strengthen Audit Readiness
Businesses with robust internal systems are far less likely to attract ATO attention. Accurate reporting, reconciled records, and defensible financial decisions create transparency, reducing your audit profile before any lodgement is made. In 2025, the ATO expects businesses to demonstrate strong internal controls, not just accurate tax calculations.
STP Reporting and Payroll Accuracy
Single Touch Payroll (STP) reporting is now a mandatory and fully integrated part of the ATO’s data infrastructure. Every time you process payroll, key data points are sent directly to the ATO, including wages, super contributions, and PAYG withholding.
When STP data doesn’t reconcile with your BAS or income tax lodgements, it creates an immediate inconsistency. This applies across reporting periods and across entities where staff may work across multiple ABNs. Even simple oversights, such as super paid late or payroll coded incorrectly, can lead to discrepancy alerts.
Ensuring accurate payroll categorisation and STP alignment is critical. This is especially important for businesses in high-scrutiny sectors such as healthcare, transport, and professional services, where employee obligations often overlap with contractor payments.
We support clients in ensuring STP lodgements reflect actual payroll activity, reducing the likelihood of automated reviews based on payroll anomalies.
Using Bookkeeping to Defend Deductions and Income
Good bookkeeping is no longer about reconciling the books once a quarter, it’s about building a real-time evidence trail. The ATO’s data-matching capabilities mean that any claim, whether for motor vehicle use, travel, depreciation, or subscriptions, must be aligned with a logical and provable business purpose.
Bank feeds, receipts, and payment confirmations must match the categorisation in your accounting system. Misclassification of income or expenses, especially in multi-entity environments, is one of the most common causes of audit escalation.
Our bookkeeping approach aligns each transaction with its appropriate tax treatment before it reaches your return. We embed evidentiary logic into each claim so that if the ATO does ask questions, the answers are already built into your general ledger.
Businesses operating in e-commerce, food and beverage, or property development, where volume and complexity are high, benefit significantly from proactive categorisation and record automation. For many of our clients, this bookkeeping-first model feeds directly into our Tax Compliance and advisory processes.
Why CFO-Level Insight Matters for Mid-Market Firms
For mid-market businesses managing multiple stakeholders, investment rounds, or international transactions, financial oversight must go beyond bookkeeping. A virtual CFO model adds structure, forecasting, and strategic awareness across tax and commercial outcomes.
CFO-level support helps businesses:
- Identify tax risk in real time
- Build compliance into financial modelling
- Structure inter-entity transactions for audit readiness
- Forecast GST, PAYG, and super obligations for cash flow certainty
This is particularly valuable for firms scaling into new markets, restructuring for tax efficiency, or preparing for capital events. We work with leaders across tech, professional services, and logistics sectors to deliver advisory support that aligns financial control with tax visibility.
Explore our CFO Services to see how proactive financial leadership supports smarter audit defence.
BAS Lodgement Due Dates
The ATO doesn’t apply the same audit criteria across every industry. Each sector has unique financial behaviours, reporting quirks, and risk thresholds. In 2025, the ATO continues to refine its data benchmarks by industry, flagging businesses whose lodgements fall outside expected patterns for their sector.
Construction & Property
In the construction sector, the ATO closely monitors GST treatment across project phases, particularly for developers and contractors working on multi-stage projects. Misclassifying capital works, incorrectly timing GST credits, or underreporting progress claims can all trigger audits.
Common ATO focus points include:
- Claiming GST on purchases not yet invoiced
- Underreporting taxable income on staged developments
- Misusing input credits on land acquisition and subdivision
- Rental vs development activity misclassification in related entities
The Taxable Payments Annual Report (TPAR) is also a high-risk area for businesses engaging contractors. Incorrect or incomplete TPAR lodgements often lead to follow-up. For developers using complex structures with trusts, companies, and SMSFs, clarity of role and purpose must be documented.
We provide comprehensive support for property and construction clients through our industry-specific tax planning services, helping navigate both tax efficiency and ATO scrutiny.
E-commerce & Retail
E-commerce businesses face unique audit challenges due to fragmented income sources, payment gateways, and global logistics. The ATO matches data from PayPal, Stripe, Shopify, and Amazon with reported income. Gaps between platform revenue and BAS declarations are commonly reviewed.
Key red flags include:
- Underreported international sales where GST thresholds apply
- Use of offshore warehousing without proper customs reporting
- Currency conversion inconsistencies in revenue recognition
- Unexplained inventory write-downs or large COGS claims
Retail businesses also face increased scrutiny on cash vs card income splits, GST rounding issues, and under-declared takings in POS systems. For growing businesses scaling across multiple platforms or borders, audit exposure grows with each new jurisdiction.
We assist e-commerce brands in building a clean digital tax footprint, ensuring that payments, stock control, and revenue align across systems and tax lodgements.
Professional Services
Service-based businesses, especially in law, consulting, health, and finance, face ATO review around two key issues: income splitting and overuse of related-party payments.
Audit triggers often arise from:
- Splitting income between family members without commercial rationale
- Paying large consulting fees to entities owned by principals
- Personal use of business accounts or assets without FBT disclosure
- Mismatches between director drawings and reported wages
The ATO uses benchmarking and lifestyle data to assess whether declared income aligns with business activity and personal spending. Structuring matters, but substance and documentation matter more.
For businesses in professional services, our tax advisory team supports clients in creating clear, defensible structures and resolving legacy tax exposure through private rulings or voluntary disclosure.
Is Your Business Structurally Exposed?
Your tax structure defines more than your profit distribution, it determines your exposure to audit risk. In 2025, the ATO continues to review multi-entity arrangements, especially where trusts, companies, directors, and SMSFs are involved in overlapping financial flows.
Multiple Entities with Poor Segregation
Running multiple businesses or investment vehicles under separate ABNs can be effective for tax planning, but only when the financial separation is genuine and traceable. The ATO examines whether revenue, expenses, and responsibilities are appropriately isolated across each entity.
Audit red flags in this space include:
- Inter-entity loans with no documentation or terms
- Expenses claimed across entities without commercial reason
- Director remuneration split between entities to manipulate tax outcomes
- Using one entity’s bank account to pay for another’s costs
These issues often surface in property development groups, retail franchises, or professional services firms with multiple trust-company hybrids. The ATO uses cross-entity data linking and director-level mapping to detect blurred lines, especially when entities share addresses, IP, or staff.
If your group structure has not been reviewed recently, Blackwattle Tax offers strategic structure diagnostics and remediation plans as part of our Tax Advisory and CFO Services. We ensure every dollar sits in the right place, and that every link is defensible.
Restructuring and Division 296 Risks
With the introduction of Division 296, businesses using SMSFs and high-balance superannuation strategies must now reassess their structural decisions. The ATO is increasingly reviewing non-arm’s length income (NALI), related-party transactions, and concessional contribution patterns for tax arbitrage behaviour.
Issues arise when:
- SMSFs are used to acquire assets from related parties at undervalue
- Property developments are undertaken using SMSF loans
- Super balances exceed $3 million, triggering additional tax under Division 296
If you operate a group that includes an SMSF, you must document the purpose and pricing of every transaction between your personal and business entities. Failing to do so creates exposure not only to audits, but to Division 296 assessments, which apply additional 15% tax on affected balances.
We regularly work with clients navigating these complexities, particularly those in property and investment-heavy structures. Our recent insight on Division 296 and SMSF planning outlines how to stay compliant under the new regime while maintaining strategic flexibility.
How Blackwattle Tax Prepares Clients for the ATO’s New Audit Climate
In a tax environment shaped by real-time data, advanced analytics, and tighter review thresholds, audit defence begins before lodgement. At Blackwattle Tax, we partner with business owners, directors, and CFOs to identify risk before the ATO does, and to structure operations that meet both tax efficiency and compliance integrity.
Our approach to audit-readiness includes:
- Pre-lodgement compliance reviews for BAS, payroll, and income tax returns
- ATO-aligned bookkeeping systems that match reporting standards.
- Tax advisory for inter-entity strategy, GST treatment, and payroll integrity
- Industry-specific planning for property, e-commerce, professional services, and transport
- Ongoing governance support through our virtual CFO Services platform
Our directors, Peter Economos and Jober Salar, bring top-tier tax advisory experience from global firms and combine it with a deep understanding of mid-market operational needs. Their technical insight, paired with proactive engagement, ensures our clients don’t get caught off guard when the ATO sharpens its focus.
Explore our Tax Advisory capabilities or meet our full Blackwattle team to see how we align tax confidence with commercial performance.
Audit-Readiness Is a Competitive Advantage in 2025
Being audit-ready isn’t simply about reducing risk, it’s about building a business that can scale, report accurately, and withstand regulatory oversight without distraction. The businesses most vulnerable to audit consequences in 2025 are those with reactive reporting, misaligned structures, or unclear financial narratives.
We help you build tax logic into your operations, so every decision is traceable, every dollar is explained, and every report reflects your true financial position. Whether you’ve already reviewed our recent insight on the ATO’s 2025 Tax Time Hitlist or are navigating complex structures, now is the time to assess your audit posture.
Book your free 30-minute strategy session with our advisory team and take the first step toward smarter compliance and stronger tax control.
Schedule a FREE 30-minute consultation today to discover how we can help you make strategic decisions and streamline your business operations.
Stay informed and empowered by subscribing to our monthly newsletter, where you’ll receive valuable insights on business advice, investment tips, and strategic tax planning.
Disclaimer: We endeavour to make sure the information provided in this guidance is up to date and accurate. Please note, that the information is only intended to be a guide, with a general overview of information. This guidance is not a comprehensive document and should not be interpreted as legal advice or tax advice. The information is general in nature. You should seek the assistance of a professional opinion for any legal and tax issues related to your personal circumstances.
